The AR-15 platform's modularity is a significant part of its appeal, but some features evoke a strong sense of nostalgia and tactical history. The carry handle upper receiver, with its integrated rear sight, is one such feature. While not as prevalent as modern flattop designs, the carry handle remains a topic of interest for shooters, collectors, and enthusiasts. This guide delves into the world of AR-15 carry handle sights, exploring their history, advantages, disadvantages, and considerations for modern use.
A Blast from the Past: The History of the Carry Handle
The carry handle upper receiver wasn't just a design choice; it was a practical solution born from the M16's early development. Integrating the rear sight directly into the upper receiver provided a robust, reliable sighting system that was integral to the weapon's design. This eliminated the need for separate mounting systems, simplifying the rifle's construction and potentially reducing manufacturing costs. The design also offered a convenient carrying handle, hence the name.
Advantages of AR-15 Carry Handle Sights
Despite the rise of flattop uppers, carry handle sights still offer certain advantages:
-
Robustness: The integrated design is inherently stronger and more resistant to damage than many aftermarket sights. It's less likely to be knocked out of alignment or broken under harsh conditions.
-
Co-witnessing: With the rise of red dot sights, the carry handle's height can be advantageous for creating a co-witness setup. This allows for quick target acquisition with the iron sights as a backup if the red dot fails.
-
Nostalgia and Authenticity: For many, the carry handle represents a classic look and feel of the original M16 design, offering a connection to military history and a distinctive aesthetic.
-
Simplicity: The fewer moving parts translate to fewer potential points of failure.
Disadvantages of AR-15 Carry Handle Sights
However, the carry handle design also has several drawbacks to consider:
-
Limited Sight Radius: The shorter sight radius compared to a flattop setup with a rear sight mounted further back can impact accuracy at longer ranges.
-
Weight: The integrated sight adds weight to the upper receiver, potentially impacting overall balance and maneuverability.
-
Optics Limitations: The carry handle's presence restricts the mounting options for optics, making it incompatible with many scopes and red dot sights without significant modifications or the use of offset mounts.
-
Height: The raised height can make it more challenging to use with certain body types or shooting positions.
Modern Applications and Considerations
While not as common as they once were, AR-15 carry handle uppers still find their place in specific applications:
-
Retro builds: Many enthusiasts enjoy building AR-15s that replicate classic M16 configurations, with the carry handle as a key component.
-
Co-witness setups (with limitations): As mentioned, it can be used effectively as a co-witness setup for red dots with careful consideration of the sight picture.
-
Budget-friendly options: A complete carry handle upper can sometimes be found at a lower price point than purchasing a flattop upper and separate sights individually.
Choosing the Right Setup: Carry Handle or Flattop?
The choice between a carry handle upper and a flattop upper largely depends on individual preferences and intended use. Flattop uppers offer greater versatility in optics mounting and sighting systems, while carry handle uppers provide a robust, integrated solution with a unique aesthetic appeal. Consider your priorities, budget, and intended applications before making your decision. Whether you're a collector, a competition shooter, or a recreational user, understanding the advantages and disadvantages of the carry handle sight is crucial to making an informed choice.
