Can a Non-Newtonian Fluid Stop a Bullet? The Science Behind the Myth
The internet is awash with videos showing seemingly incredible feats: hands plunging into pools of seemingly harmless ooze, only to meet impenetrable resistance; objects dropped onto the surface bouncing harmlessly; and the most dramatic of all – bullets seemingly stopped dead in their tracks. These are all demonstrations often attributed to the magic of non-Newtonian fluids. But can a non-Newtonian fluid really stop a bullet? The short answer is: it's complicated, and the simple answer is likely no.
While the captivating visuals are undeniable, the reality is far more nuanced than a simple yes or no. Let's delve into the science to understand why.
Understanding Non-Newtonian Fluids
Non-Newtonian fluids are substances that don't follow the typical rules of Newtonian fluids (like water). Their viscosity – their resistance to flow – changes depending on the amount of stress applied. A classic example is cornstarch and water mixture: slowly pour your hand in, and it flows; punch it, and it feels solid. This change in viscosity is key to the perceived bullet-stopping abilities.
The Myth Debunked (Mostly)
The videos demonstrating bullets being stopped by non-Newtonian fluids often utilize specific setups and conditions that exaggerate the effect. The key factors are:
-
Bullet Velocity and Mass: The energy of a bullet fired from a firearm is immense. Even a relatively slow-moving bullet carries significant kinetic energy. While a non-Newtonian fluid can absorb a considerable amount of energy, it's debatable whether a typical setup can halt a bullet entirely. The fluid’s resistance increases with applied force, but that force is also incredibly high in the case of a bullet.
-
Depth of the Fluid: A shallow pool of non-Newtonian fluid wouldn't offer nearly enough resistance. The depth required to significantly slow or stop a bullet would need to be substantial, potentially several feet.
-
Fluid Composition: The precise recipe of the non-Newtonian fluid plays a critical role. Different concentrations of cornstarch and water, or other ingredients, drastically alter the fluid's properties. A precisely formulated fluid might offer greater resistance than a typical home-made mixture.
-
Bullet Type and Caliber: The size, shape, and velocity of the bullet itself drastically affect its ability to penetrate the fluid. A smaller, slower-moving bullet might be more easily stopped than a high-velocity, larger caliber round.
The Reality: Significant Slowing, Not Complete Stopping
It's more accurate to say that a sufficiently deep and correctly formulated non-Newtonian fluid can significantly slow down a bullet, potentially reducing its penetration power. This slowing is due to the rapid increase in viscosity as the bullet impacts the fluid, creating immense resistance. However, complete stoppage requires a substantially larger amount of fluid and very specific parameters; in most scenarios, the bullet is likely to still penetrate, even if significantly slowed.
Conclusion
While the visual demonstrations of non-Newtonian fluids stopping bullets are compelling, they often oversimplify the complex physics involved. The claims should be viewed with a healthy dose of skepticism. While the fluids can absorb significant energy and slow down projectiles, complete stoppage remains unlikely under most realistic conditions. The fascinating properties of these fluids warrant further research, but the "bullet-stopping" claim remains largely a matter of dramatic demonstration rather than scientific fact.
