Does Steel Case Ammo Damage Guns? The Comprehensive Guide
The question of whether steel case ammo damages guns is a hotly debated topic among firearms enthusiasts. The short answer is: it can, but it's not a guaranteed outcome. The extent of the damage, if any, depends on several factors. This guide delves into the details, helping you understand the potential risks and make informed decisions.
Understanding the Differences: Steel vs. Brass Case Ammo
Before diving into the potential damage, it's crucial to understand the fundamental differences between steel and brass cased ammunition.
-
Brass Case Ammo: Traditionally, ammunition uses brass casings. Brass is a relatively soft, malleable metal that expands upon firing, sealing the chamber and facilitating reliable extraction. Its softness also helps prevent damage to the firearm's internal components.
-
Steel Case Ammo: Steel casings are harder and less malleable than brass. This hardness can lead to increased friction and wear on the firearm's components. Additionally, steel cases are often coated to prevent corrosion, and these coatings can sometimes leave residue that builds up inside the firearm.
Potential Damage from Steel Case Ammo
While steel case ammo isn't inherently destructive, several issues can arise from its use:
-
Increased Wear and Tear: The harder steel casing can cause increased friction on the gun's extractor and ejector, potentially leading to premature wear and malfunctions. This is especially true with high-round counts.
-
Extractor Damage: The increased friction can damage the extractor, a crucial part responsible for pulling the spent casing from the chamber. A damaged extractor can result in malfunctions, jams, and even the inability to cycle the action correctly.
-
Ejector Damage: Similar to the extractor, the ejector can also suffer from increased wear due to the harder steel case. A damaged ejector may cause spent cases to fail to eject properly, leading to jams and potential safety hazards.
-
Chamber Abrasion: Over time, the harder steel casing can cause minor abrasions within the firearm's chamber. While these may not always be immediately noticeable, they can contribute to long-term wear and tear.
-
Residue Buildup: The coatings on steel case ammo often leave residue that can accumulate within the firearm. This residue can gum up moving parts, contribute to malfunctions, and even lead to corrosion if not regularly cleaned.
Factors Influencing Damage:
Several factors influence whether steel case ammo will damage your firearm:
-
Type of Firearm: Some firearms are more susceptible to damage from steel case ammo than others. Generally, semi-automatic firearms are more prone to issues than revolvers.
-
Quality of Steel Case Ammo: Not all steel case ammo is created equal. Lower-quality ammunition may exhibit more problems than higher-quality options.
-
Frequency of Use: Occasional use of steel case ammo is likely less problematic than constant or heavy use.
-
Cleaning and Maintenance: Regular cleaning and maintenance can mitigate many potential problems associated with steel case ammo use. Frequent cleaning helps remove residue and prevents the buildup that can lead to malfunctions.
Conclusion: Proceed with Caution
While steel case ammo can be significantly cheaper than brass, its potential for increased wear and tear on your firearm is a factor to consider. If you choose to use it, understand the potential risks, use high-quality steel-cased ammunition where possible, clean your firearm frequently, and monitor it closely for signs of wear and tear. For many firearms, brass-cased ammunition remains the better choice for long-term reliability and performance.
