Choosing between the Glock 17 Gen 4 and Gen 5 can feel overwhelming. Both are highly regarded handguns, but subtle yet significant differences exist that cater to different preferences and shooting styles. This in-depth comparison will delve into the key features, highlighting the advantages and disadvantages of each generation to help you make an informed decision.
Key Differences: A Head-to-Head Comparison
Both the Glock 17 Gen 4 and Gen 5 are full-size, 9mm pistols known for their reliability and durability. However, Glock introduced several refinements in the Gen 5 model. Let's break down the crucial distinctions:
1. Trigger: Enhanced Performance and Feel
- Gen 4: Features the now-classic Glock "safe action" trigger with a slightly rougher, textured surface. This provides a consistent, reliable trigger pull, although some shooters find it slightly less refined than the Gen 5.
- Gen 5: Boasts an improved trigger with a smoother, less textured surface. This results in a crisper, cleaner break, often praised for its enhanced feel and improved accuracy potential. The trigger also features an incorporated trigger safety.
Verdict: The Gen 5's trigger is generally considered superior, offering a more refined and comfortable shooting experience.
2. Slide: Streamlined for Enhanced Operation
- Gen 4: Includes front and rear serrations, providing multiple gripping points for manipulation. The added texturing aids in slide racking, particularly in adverse conditions.
- Gen 5: Features ambidextrous slide serrations, which are more aggressive and offer improved control during slide manipulation. Glock also removed the finger grooves on the Gen 5 slide, contributing to a more streamlined design and potentially a more comfortable grip for various hand sizes.
Verdict: The Gen 5's ambidextrous slide serrations and the absence of finger grooves provide a more modern, versatile design. The improved aggressive serrations are a significant improvement for many shooters.
3. Magazine Release: Ambidextrous Functionality
- Gen 4: Offers a reversible magazine release, allowing for easy left-handed use via a simple swap.
- Gen 5: Also features a reversible magazine release, continuing the user-friendly ambidextrous design. The Gen 5's release may feel slightly different due to the changes in overall grip texture.
Verdict: Both generations offer excellent ambidextrous compatibility. The functionality remains consistent, with little difference impacting the user experience.
4. Grips and Texture: Enhanced Control and Ergonomics
- Gen 4: Includes interchangeable backstraps, allowing shooters to customize the grip to their hand size and preferences. This is a significant feature for enhancing comfort and control.
- Gen 5: Eliminates the interchangeable backstraps, opting for a more aggressive, textured grip surface on the frame. While losing the customization of backstraps, the improved texturing enhances grip, particularly in wet or sweaty conditions.
Verdict: The Gen 4’s interchangeable backstraps offer a wider range of customization, making it more adaptable to individual hand sizes. The Gen 5's aggressive texturing is appreciated by many, though some may miss the customization option.
5. Overall Weight and Feel: Minor Differences
- Gen 4: Slightly heavier due to the inclusion of the interchangeable backstraps.
- Gen 5: Slightly lighter due to the removal of the backstraps and some minor internal design adjustments.
Verdict: The weight difference is negligible for most shooters and won't significantly impact handling or performance.
Which Generation is Right for You?
The choice ultimately depends on individual preferences and priorities.
-
Choose the Glock 17 Gen 4 if: You prioritize customizable grip options to perfectly fit your hand size and prefer a slightly more textured trigger.
-
Choose the Glock 17 Gen 5 if: You value a smoother trigger, more aggressive slide serrations, and a more streamlined, modern design. The absence of finger grooves might also be preferable for shooters with various hand sizes.
Both are reliable, accurate, and durable handguns. Consider handling both models if possible to determine which feels better in your hand and better suits your shooting style. Ultimately, the "best" Glock is the one that fits you best.
