A background check denial from the National Instant Criminal Background Check System (NICS) can be frustrating, especially after you've worked to clear your record through expungement. This guide explores the complexities of NICS denials following expungement, outlining the reasons for such denials and the steps you can take to address them.
Understanding Expungement and NICS
Expungement, also known as sealing or setting aside a record, aims to remove certain criminal convictions from your official record. However, expungement doesn't automatically guarantee the removal of information from all databases, including those used by NICS. The success of an expungement in preventing a NICS denial depends heavily on state and federal laws, the specific details of your case, and the thoroughness of the expungement process.
Why You Might Still Face a NICS Denial After Expungement
Several reasons can contribute to a NICS denial despite a successful expungement:
-
Incomplete Expungement: State laws vary significantly. Some expungements only partially remove information, leaving enough data to trigger a NICS denial. The specifics of your expungement order are critical. Did it explicitly state the removal of the relevant information from all databases, including those used for firearms background checks? If not, your expungement might be insufficient.
-
Federal Databases: Even a complete state-level expungement may not affect federal databases used by NICS. Federal law may still prohibit firearm ownership due to the nature of your prior conviction, regardless of your state's expungement.
-
Data Lag: There can be a significant delay between the court's expungement order and the actual updating of NICS and other relevant databases. The information might still show up in the system while the update is pending.
-
Misinterpretation of the Expungement Order: The person conducting the NICS background check might misinterpret the expungement order or fail to recognize its validity. Human error unfortunately plays a role in these processes.
-
Other Prohibitions: Even with a clean record post-expungement, you might still be prohibited from owning firearms due to other factors, such as a history of domestic violence or mental health adjudications.
Recourse After a NICS Denial
If you face a NICS denial after expungement, you should:
-
Review Your Expungement Order: Carefully examine the legal documentation to determine the scope of the expungement. It should explicitly detail what information is removed and from which databases.
-
Contact Your Attorney: Legal counsel familiar with firearms laws and NICS procedures can provide valuable assistance in navigating this complex process. They can help you understand your rights and options for appeal.
-
Appeal the NICS Denial: The NICS appeal process allows individuals to challenge denials based on errors or outdated information. This process is intricate and involves providing substantial documentation to support your claim.
-
Seek Legal Assistance with NICS Appeal: Navigating the NICS appeal is often complex and time-consuming. Experienced legal representation can significantly improve your chances of a successful appeal.
Prevention is Key
While a NICS denial after expungement is challenging to overcome, careful planning before attempting expungement can help reduce the risk:
-
Consult with an Attorney: Before pursuing expungement, seek legal advice to ensure the process addresses all relevant databases, including those used for NICS checks.
-
Thorough Understanding of State and Federal Law: Understand the limitations of expungement under state and federal law regarding firearm ownership.
Dealing with a NICS denial after expungement is a complex legal matter. Proactive steps and qualified legal representation are crucial to protecting your rights and increasing your chances of a successful resolution. This information is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Always consult with a legal professional for advice tailored to your specific situation.
