Choosing the right subcompact pistol is a crucial decision, especially for concealed carry. SIG Sauer's P320 family offers two popular contenders in this arena: the P320 Compact and the P320 Carry. While seemingly similar, key differences exist that significantly impact their suitability for various users and carry styles. This detailed comparison will dissect the nuances of each model, helping you determine which pistol best fits your needs.
Size and Weight: The Pocket-Sized Powerhouse Debate
The most immediate distinction lies in their dimensions. The P320 Compact boasts a slightly larger grip and slide, translating to a more substantial feel in hand. This added size provides a more stable shooting platform, particularly beneficial for those with larger hands. The extra real estate also allows for slightly improved sight radius, aiding in accuracy.
The P320 Carry, conversely, prioritizes concealability. Its smaller grip and reduced overall dimensions make it ideal for deep concealment, fitting comfortably in smaller pockets or appendix carry setups. However, this compactness comes at the cost of potentially reduced shootability for individuals with smaller hands.
In short:
- P320 Compact: Larger, more stable, better shootability.
- P320 Carry: Smaller, easier to conceal, potentially less comfortable for larger hands.
Capacity: How Much Ammo Matters
While both models utilize the same 9mm cartridge, magazine capacity differs. The P320 Compact typically ships with magazines holding 15 rounds (though higher-capacity options exist), while the P320 Carry often comes with 12-round magazines. This difference, though seemingly small, becomes significant during extended engagements or self-defense scenarios.
In short:
- P320 Compact: Higher magazine capacity (typically 15 rounds).
- P320 Carry: Lower magazine capacity (typically 12 rounds).
Ergonomics and Handling: Comfort and Control
Both pistols benefit from the P320's modularity, allowing for customization of grip modules to fit different hand sizes. This is a crucial feature ensuring comfortable and controlled shooting for a broader range of users. However, the larger grip of the Compact provides a more substantial and arguably more comfortable feel for many shooters, leading to improved recoil management.
In short:
- P320 Compact: Larger grip, generally perceived as more comfortable for many.
- P320 Carry: Smaller grip, may be more comfortable for individuals with smaller hands.
Concealability: The Ultimate Test for Subcompacts
Concealability is paramount in a subcompact pistol. The P320 Carry's smaller profile makes it a clear winner in this category. It's significantly easier to conceal under clothing, particularly with appendix or pocket carry methods. The P320 Compact, while still concealable, requires more effort and may print more noticeably depending on the clothing worn.
In short:
- P320 Compact: Concealable, but requires more effort and may print more readily.
- P320 Carry: Superior concealability, ideal for deep concealment methods.
The Verdict: Choosing Your Champion
Ultimately, the "better" pistol depends entirely on individual needs and preferences. The P320 Compact excels in shootability and capacity, making it ideal for those prioritizing accuracy and carrying extra ammunition. The P320 Carry, however, takes the crown in concealability, prioritizing discretion and ease of carrying for everyday situations.
Before making a purchase, consider your hand size, intended carry method, and desired level of concealability. Renting or handling both models at a local range is highly recommended to make an informed decision and choose the subcompact 9mm that best suits your needs.
