Will a Glock 17 Fit in a Glock 19 Holster? The Definitive Answer
The short answer is no, a Glock 17 will generally not fit in a holster designed specifically for a Glock 19. While they share a similar design philosophy, the Glock 17 is significantly longer than the Glock 19, making it incompatible with most holsters intended for the smaller model.
Let's delve into the specifics to understand why:
Key Differences Between Glock 17 and Glock 19
The primary difference responsible for the incompatibility lies in the slide length. The Glock 17's longer slide extends beyond the retention area of a Glock 19 holster, preventing proper insertion and secure retention. This difference in slide length also impacts the overall length of the firearm. Other minor differences, while not always the primary cause of incompatibility, include the slightly different grip texture and potentially the trigger guard shape depending on the holster design.
Why Trying to Force a Fit is Dangerous
Attempting to force a Glock 17 into a Glock 19 holster is extremely risky and should be avoided entirely. Here's why:
- Unsafe Retention: The holster's retention mechanism, designed for the shorter Glock 19, won't properly engage with the longer Glock 17. This can lead to the firearm accidentally dislodging from the holster, posing a significant safety hazard.
- Holster Damage: Forcing a larger gun into a smaller holster can damage the holster itself, rendering it unusable and potentially compromising its integrity.
- Weapon Damage: The stress of forcing the fit might potentially damage the firearm, particularly the slide or trigger mechanism.
What to Do Instead
If you own both a Glock 17 and a Glock 19, the best solution is to purchase separate holsters for each firearm. Investing in quality holsters specifically designed for each model will ensure proper fit, secure retention, and ultimately, a safer carry experience. Consider factors like your intended carry method (inside the waistband, outside the waistband, etc.) when selecting your holsters. Many reputable holster manufacturers offer a wide variety of options tailored to specific Glock models and carry styles.
Understanding Holster Compatibility
Remember, even within the same Glock family, subtle variations in holster designs can impact compatibility. Always double-check the manufacturer's specifications to confirm the holster is explicitly designed for your specific Glock model. Never assume compatibility based solely on the general Glock model number.
In conclusion, while some might try unconventional methods, forcing a Glock 17 into a Glock 19 holster is a dangerous practice that should never be attempted. Prioritizing safety and investing in appropriate holsters for each firearm is crucial for responsible gun ownership.
